Mount Pinatubo's 1991 eruption in the Phillippines injected sulfates into the atmosphere and cooled the earth. One geoengineering scheme would potentially replicate the cooling effects of volcanic eruptions. Photo: D. Harlow, USGS.
Would massive crop failures from heat waves and drought in the grain-growing regions of the American midwest be a sufficient reason to intentionally manipulate the atmosphere and cool the earth?
That was the opening question posed by Ken Caldeira of the Carnegie Institution and Stanford during a recent panel discussion on geoengineering at the Aspen Environment Forum. (Disclosure: I helped organize the session and event.)
This question of "geoengineering" -- whether, when, and how to intentionally change earth's atmosphere -- is poised for more attention as the carbon pollution we unintentionally produce by burning coal and oil keeps rising. As atmospheric carbon dioxide levels rise, they trap more of the sun's reflected radiant energy near the earth and drive up land and ocean temperatures.
And as temperatures go up, droughts already seen in Australia's Murray-Darling basin, or heatwaves that hit Europe in 2003 likely will become the norm, according to scientists such as David Battisti and Rosamond Naylor. Their study published in SCIENCE this year examines the likelihood and potential impact of future heatwaves on food supply as carbon emissions and temperatures rise.
Jamais Cascio, a founder of worldchanging.org and now writing at Open the Future published in early 2009 a very readable and insightful short book on this subject, "Hacking the Earth: Understanding the Consequences of Geoengineering." Cascio lays out the choices and ethical implications of "geoengineering" the atmosphere to control planetary heating.
In theory, several options exist: shoot sulfate particles or millions of light-reflecting disks high into the atmosphere to block the sun; fertilize the oceans with iron to encourage carbon-absorbing phytoplankton blooms; plant millions of trees to absorb carbon; spray seawater into the sky to create heat-reflecting white clouds; and somehow capture and bury carbon already in the sky.
So what to do as our rising carbon emissions heat the planet? Is there any realistic large-scale way to cool earth, or stem the heating? Volcanic eruptions have, and a recent example is the Phillippines' Mount Pinatubo. In 1991 the volcano cooled the earth when its eruptions injected massive amounts of sulfates into the atmosphere, partially blocking the sun.